Hurtling toward the tax bill’s unintended consequences
Assuming the GOP tax overhaul passes, it’s going to take effect in about three weeks. That’s not much time to digest a once-in-a-generation change to the tax code, even if you’re an expert in this sort of thing. The bill was written at break-neck speed as well, which means that if you’ve got an enterprising accountant, there may be room to game the system. Marketplace host Kai Ryssdal spoke with Martin Sullivan, the chief economist at Tax Analysts, a nonprofit that — you guessed it — analyzes the tax code, about what the unintended consequences of this speedy tax overhaul could be. The following is an edited transcript of their conversation.
Kai Ryssdal: This was a bill that was put together with some degree of haste, Mr. Sullivan, and I guess the question is does that increase the opportunity for unintended consequences — not loopholes — but unintended consequences?
Martin Sullivan: Well, I think there has been tremendous haste in this bill. Back in 1986, it took 13 months to do the tax reform bill. We’re trying to do it in 13 weeks. And it has created a tremendous number of unintended consequences, some of which are just being unearthed, some of which I’m sure we’re going to find in the future.
Ryssdal: Do you have a favorite? I mean, there’s lots of unintended consequences, lots of things in this bill. What’s your favorite? Pick one.
Sullivan: Well, I guess if I have to pick one, the one that I think is most interesting is how they’re going to divide in a small business the wages which will be subject to a high tax rate from the profits which will be subject to a low tax rate. So in a small business, if I’m the owner, how do I divide what I should be paid as a worker from what I should be paid as a capitalist? And there’s no bright line between those.
Ryssdal: This is that thing known as pass-through, right?
Sullivan: That’s correct.
Ryssdal: OK. So what is to stop me or anybody else in this economy who is just going to work every day from making themselves into a pass-through corporation — and yes Congress is putting guardrails in there — but come on, we know smart tax lawyers can figure this out for us. And I get the lower rate, right?
Sullivan: The bill is still in flux. But it looks like if you’re under $500,000 of income, you will be able to incorporate yourself and then make a contract with your employer. The income that you receive instead of wages would be considered a tax-preferred income, and you pay a lower rate.
Ryssdal: As we know, this bill is going to pass before Christmas. It’s going to pass the House, it’s going to pass the Senate, and then the president is going to sign it, and then 1 January 2018 these things go into effect, right?
Sullivan: Yes, that’s correct.
Ryssdal: We’re inside a matter of weeks before this takes effect?
Sullivan: Yeah. Well, for the large business community, there’s going to be a tremendous amount of reshuffling of their financial statements to comply with the new rules. It’s going to be a tremendous burden on the tax departments of the Fortune 500 companies because they have to literally rethink everything they do with taxes. And we still don’t even know what’s final in the bill. Maybe it’s a Christmas present for most of America, but it’s certainly not a Christmas present for America’s accountants.
Ryssdal: One of the things that happened with the last really big piece of controversial legislation in this country, the Affordable Care Act, was that a lot was left to regulators to implement the rules for and then figure out. Does the same thing happen in tax land? I mean, we’re going to pass this tax bill and then somebody is going to have to figure out the rules, right?
Sullivan: Well, always after a major tax bill there are technical corrections that are done by Congress and regulations that are done by the Treasury Department. But for this bill, there is almost certainly going to be a long process of writing regulations and writing another law to fix all the errors in the current law.
| Key differences in the House and Senate tax bills, and who is likely to win |
| What’s next for the tax bill? |
| Why the pass through tax is important for business |
There’s a lot happening in the world. Through it all, Marketplace is here for you.
You rely on Marketplace to break down the world’s events and tell you how it affects you in a fact-based, approachable way. We rely on your financial support to keep making that possible.
Your donation today powers the independent journalism that you rely on. For just $5/month, you can help sustain Marketplace so we can keep reporting on the things that matter to you.
